• The Yankees are -140 favorites vs the Blue Jays
• Blue Jays vs Yankees Over / Under today: 8.5 Runs
• Blue Jays / Yankees TV Channel: TBS | YES | RSN1

The Toronto Blue Jays (+115) visit Yankee Stadium to take on the New York Yankees (-140) on May 19, 2026. First pitch is scheduled for 7:05 pm in Bronx, NY.

This season, the Blue Jays are 21-26 against the spread (ATS), while the Yankees are 25-22 ATS.

Blue Jays vs Yankees Starting Pitchers Today:

• Blue Jays starting pitcher: Dylan Cease 3-1, 2.41 ERA
• Yankees starting pitcher: Will Warren 5-1, 3.40 ERA

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds, Run Line, Over/Under & Moneyline

Blue Jays vs Yankees Prediction for Today’s Game

Based on recent trends the model predicts the Yankees will win Tuesday‘s MLB game with 55.6% confidence, factoring in game simulations, recent player performances, starting pitchers and injuries.

Bet now on Blue Jays vs Yankees and all games with BetMGM

We’ve highlighted some favorite MLB player prop bets for Blue Jays players for Tuesday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Blue Jays Player Prop Bets Today:

• Kazuma Okamoto has hit the Home Runs Over in 4 of his last 9 away games (+13.40 Units / 149% ROI)
• Jesus Sanchez has hit the Runs Under in 14 of his last 15 away games (+12.30 Units / 44% ROI)
• Tyler Heineman has hit the Hits Runs and RBIs Under in 12 of his last 15 games (+10.45 Units / 61% ROI)
• George Springer has hit the Hits Under in 15 of his last 25 games (+10.45 Units / 29% ROI)
• Tyler Heineman has hit the Total Bases Under in 12 of his last 15 games (+8.95 Units / 54% ROI)

And here are some favorite MLB player prop bets for Yankees players for Tuesday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Yankees Player Prop Best Bets Today:

• Ryan McMahon has hit the Walks Under in 23 of his last 25 games (+18.90 Units / 34% ROI)
• Ben Rice has hit the Home Runs Over in 6 of his last 8 games at home (+18.40 Units / 230% ROI)
• Cody Bellinger has hit the Hits Over in 22 of his last 25 games at home (+15.60 Units / 29% ROI)
• Cody Bellinger has hit the Total Bases Over in 9 of his last 10 games at home (+11.00 Units / 110% ROI)
• Ryan McMahon has hit the Runs Under in 20 of his last 25 games (+10.00 Units / 19% ROI)

Blue Jays Best Bets Today:

• The Toronto Blue Jays have hit the 1st Five Innings (F5) Team Total Under in 32 of their last 50 games (+13.45 Units / 23% ROI)
• The Toronto Blue Jays have hit the Team Total Under in 16 of their last 23 away games (+8.40 Units / 31% ROI)
• The Toronto Blue Jays have covered the Run Line in 14 of their last 22 games (+6.55 Units / 23% ROI)
• The Toronto Blue Jays have hit the Game Total Under in 6 of their last 8 away games (+4.90 Units / 55% ROI)
• The Toronto Blue Jays have covered the 1st Five Innings (F5) Run Line in 5 of their last 6 away games (+4.05 Units / 58% ROI)

Yankees Best Bets Today:

• The New York Yankees have covered the Run Line in 9 of their last 11 games at home (+9.15 Units / 79% ROI)
• The New York Yankees have hit the 1st Five Innings (F5) Moneyline in 30 of their last 50 games at home (+8.65 Units / 9% ROI)
• The New York Yankees have hit the Moneyline in 10 of their last 11 games at home (+8.30 Units / 42% ROI)
• The New York Yankees have hit the Team Total Over in 9 of their last 10 games at home (+7.95 Units / 69% ROI)
• The New York Yankees have hit the 1st Five Innings (F5) Team Total Under in 27 of their last 45 games (+6.45 Units / 12% ROI)

Blue Jays Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this season, the Blue Jays are 22-25 against the Run Line (-4.65 Units / -7.87% ROI).

• 21-26 when betting on the Moneyline for -12.5 Units / -19.81% ROI
• 22-23 when betting on the total runs Over for -3.3 Units / -6.36% ROI
• 23-22 when betting on the total runs Under for -0.95 Units / -1.84% ROI

Yankees Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this season, the Yankees are 25-22 against the Run Line (+7.3 Units / 14.24% ROI).

• 29-19 when betting on the Moneyline for -1.05 Units / -1.37% ROI
• 21-24 when betting on the total runs Over for -5.6 Units / -10.62% ROI
• 24-21 when betting on the total runs Under for +0.7 Units / 1.32% ROI

Yankees vs Blue Jays Home Run Prop Bets Today

Yankees vs Blue Jays Total Hits Prop Bets Today

Yankees vs Blue Jays Strikeout Prop Bets Today

Blue Jays Keys to the Game vs. the Yankees

The Blue Jays are just 2-9 (.182) vs the top 10 runs allowed teams this season Today, they face Yankees (fourth in runs allowed).

The Blue Jays are just 2-17 (.105) when allowing 5 or more runs this season — tied for 4th lowest in MLB; League Avg: .209.

The Blue Jays are just 15-4 (.789) when leading entering the 7th inning this season — 5th lowest in MLB; League Avg: .867.

The Blue Jays are just 14-3 (.824) when leading entering the 8th inning this season — 3rd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .897.

Yankees Keys to the Game vs. the Blue Jays

The Yankees are 2-13 (.133) when trailing entering the 9th inning this season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .050.

The Yankees are 14-0 (1.000) when they’ve had 10 or more hits this season — best in MLB; League Avg: .754.

The Yankees are 18-1 (.947) when they’ve hit 2 or more home runs this season — best in MLB; League Avg: .708.

The Yankees are 15-6 (.714) at home this season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .540.

Blue Jays Hitting Stats & Trends

Blue Jays hitters have struck out in just 18% of their PA’s against RHP this season — best in MLB.

Blue Jays hitters have struck out in just 18% of their PA’s this season — tied for best in MLB.

Blue Jays hitters have drawn walks in 7% of their PA’s against RHP this season — 2nd lowest in MLB.

Blue Jays hitters are averaging just 3.75 pitches per plate appearance this season — lowest in MLB.

Yankees Hitting Stats & Trends

Yankees hitters are slugging .506 at home this season — best in MLB.

Yankees hitters have 60 extra-base hits out of 129 total hits (47%) against LHP this season — best in MLB.

The Yankees are batting just .143 with two-strikes this season — lowest in MLB.

Yankees hitters are slugging .667 in non-two strike counts this season — best in MLB.

Blue Jays Pitching Stats & Trends

Blue Jays pitchers have allowed an average Exit Velocity of 87.8 MPH (1,126 batted balls) this season — 3rd best in MLB.

Blue Jays pitchers have allowed an exit velocity of 95 MPH or greater 415 times this season — 3rd fewest in MLB.

The Blue Jays pitchers have allowed an average Exit Velocity of just 87.8 MPH this season (1,126 balls in play) — 3rd best in MLB

Blue Jays pitchers have allowed 43 stolen bases this season — tied for 4th most in MLB.

Yankees Pitching Stats & Trends

Opponents have a groundball rate of 49% against Yankees pitchers this season — highest in MLB.

Yankees pitchers have an ERA of 2.98 (235.1 IP) on the road this season — best in MLB.

Yankees pitchers have a strikeout rate of 25% with runners in scoring position this season — 4th best in MLB.

Yankees pitchers have an ERA of 2.94 (122.1 IP) against division opponents this season — best in MLB.

More MLB Reading:

• Home Run Predictions Today
• Best NRFI Bets Today
• Strikeout Props Today
• MLB Starting Pitchers Today

Bet now on Blue Jays vs Yankees and all games with BetMGM

Bet on MLB Odds at BetMGM

Sportsbook promos are always available at BetMGM. For new customers, check out the sportsbook welcome offer and BetMGM Refer a Friend. For existing customers, there are Odds Boosts, Parlay Boosts, contests and more.