Yankees vs Pirates Prediction, Odds & Player Prop Bets Today – MLB, Sep 16

min read
Pittsburgh Pirates' Andrew McCutchen rounds third after hitting a solo home run off starting pitcher Freddy Peralta (51) during the fourth inning of a baseball game in Pittsburgh, Friday, June 30, 2023.
(AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)
BetMGM Betting @BETMGM Sep 16, 2023, 3:30 PM
  • The Yankees are -120 favorites vs the Pirates
  • Yankees starting pitcher: Luke Weaver
  • Pirates starting pitcher: Luis L. Ortiz
  • Watch the game on SportsNet PT

The New York Yankees (-120) visit PNC Park to take on the Pittsburgh Pirates (+100) on Saturday, September 16, 2023. First pitch is scheduled for 6:35pm EDT in Pittsburgh.

The Yankees are the betting favorite in this game, with the run line sitting at -1.5 (+135).

The Yankees vs Pirates Over/Under is 9.5 total runs for the game.

This season, the Yankees are 75-73 against the spread (ATS), while the Pirates are 74-74 ATS.

Yankees vs. Pirates Odds, Run Line, Over/Under & Moneyline

SpreadOver / UnderMoneyline
Yankees-1.5 +135O 9.5 -120-120
Pirates +1.5 -160U 9.5 +100+100

Yankees vs Pirates Prediction for Today’s Game

Based on recent trends the model predicts the Yankees will win Saturday‘s MLB matchup with 51.0% confidence.

This prediction factors in starting pitchers, recent team and player hitting performances, the last 5 games for both the Yankees and Pirates and up-to-date player injuries.


Bet now on Yankees vs Pirates and all games with BetMGM


We’ve highlighted some favorite MLB player prop bets for Yankees players for Saturday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Yankees Player Prop Bets Today:

  • Oswald Peraza has hit the Runs Under in 13 of his last 14 away games (+11.00 Units / 35% ROI)
  • Gleyber Torres has hit the Runs Over in 14 of his last 20 games (+9.40 Units / 46% ROI)
  • DJ LeMahieu has hit the Singles Under in 16 of his last 24 games (+9.05 Units / 37% ROI)
  • Anthony Volpe has hit the Singles Under in 15 of his last 19 away games (+8.75 Units / 32% ROI)
  • Oswald Peraza has hit the Hits Over in 10 of his last 11 games (+8.25 Units / 43% ROI)

And here are some favorite MLB player prop bets for Pirates players for Saturday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Pirates Player Prop Best Bets Today:

  • Bryan Reynolds has hit the Hits Over in 32 of his last 50 games (+12.25 Units / 13% ROI)
  • Bryan Reynolds has hit the Singles Over in 13 of his last 15 games (+10.60 Units / 53% ROI)
  • Ke’Bryan Hayes has hit the RBIs Over in 10 of his last 17 games (+10.05 Units / 59% ROI)
  • Bryan Reynolds has hit the Hits Runs and RBIs Over in 29 of his last 45 games (+9.10 Units / 15% ROI)
  • Bryan Reynolds has hit the RBIs Over in 6 of his last 7 games (+8.85 Units / 126% ROI)

Pirates vs Yankees Home Run Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Everson Pereira 0.5 +650 0.5 -2000
Josh Palacios 0.5 +600 0.5 -1600
Bryan Reynolds 0.5 +500 0.5 -1100
Anthony Volpe 0.5 +650 0.5 -2000
Liover Peguero 0.5 +875 0.5 -5000

Pirates vs Yankees Total Hits Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Everson Pereira 0.5 -150 0.5 +115
Josh Palacios 0.5 -225 0.5 +170
Bryan Reynolds 0.5 -250 0.5 +190
Anthony Volpe 0.5 -225 0.5 +165
Liover Peguero 0.5 -145 0.5 +110

Pirates vs Yankees RBI Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Everson Pereira 0.5 +220 0.5 -300
Josh Palacios 0.5 +180 0.5 -250
Bryan Reynolds 0.5 +155 0.5 -210
Anthony Volpe 0.5 +195 0.5 -275
RBis will Liover Peguero 0.5 +225 0.5 -300

Pirates vs Yankees Strikeout Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Luis Ortiz 4.5 -110 4.5 -120
Luke Weaver 3.5 -150 3.5 +115
  • team high – away
  • team high – home

Yankees Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this MLB season, the Yankees have gone 72-76 against the Run Line (-7.85 Units / -4.27% ROI).

  • 75-73 when betting on the Moneyline for -9.8 Units / -5.01% ROI
  • 67-76 when betting on the total runs Over for -16.25 Units / -10.01% ROI
  • 76-67 when betting on the total runs Under for +2.25 Units / 1.38% ROI

Pirates Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this MLB season, the Pirates have gone 74-74 against the Run Line (-17.4 Units / -8.95% ROI).

  • 69-79 when betting on the Moneyline for +5.45 Units / 3.36% ROI
  • 80-63 when betting on the total runs Over for +10.9 Units / 6.69% ROI
  • 63-80 when betting on the total runs Under for -24.6 Units / -15.1% ROI

Opponents had a line drive rate of just 18% (91/515) versus Chris Bassitt in 2022 — lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 23% — 100th Percentile.

Carlos Rodon has allowed at least one HR in each of his last seven games dating back to August 1st — Kenta Maeda has the longest active streak at 11.

Carlos Rodon has a strikeout rate of 38% (119 SO in 310 PAs) with runners in scoring position since the 2021 season — best in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 187 total IP; League Avg: 22% — 100th Percentile.

Opponents are hitting just .244 (22-for-90) against Carlos Rodon on the first pitch of at-bats since last season — 5th best in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 123 total IP; League Avg: .344 — 96th Percentile.

Pirates Starting Pitcher Stats & Trends

Left-handed batters are hitting .346 (45-for-130) against Luis Ortiz this season — 3rd highest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 58 total IP; League Avg: .251 — second Percentile.

Luis Ortiz has allowed an average Exit Velocity of 92.5 MPH (243 batted balls) this season — highest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 58 total IP; League Avg: 89.2 — 0 Percentile.

Luis Ortiz has not allowed a home run in any of the last 20.0 innings he’s appeared — Tanner Scott has the longest active streak at 61.1.

Luis Ortiz has a strike rate of just 61% (739/1,207) this season — 15th lowest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 58 total IP; League Avg: 64% — eighth Percentile.

Yankees Keys to the Game vs. the Pirates

The Yankees are 18-15 (.545) after a win as underdogs since last season — best in MLB; League Avg: .416.

The Yankees were 20-24 (.455) when allowing 5 or more runs in 2022 — best in MLB; League Avg: .195.

The Yankees are just 14-26 (.350) after a loss as underdogs since last season — 4th lowest in MLB; League Avg: .406.

The Yankees are 49-15 (.766) when they’ve hit 2 or more home runs this season — 4th best in MLB; League Avg: .689.

Pirates Keys to the Game vs. the Yankees

The Pirates are just 23-124 (.156) when allowing 5 or more runs since last season — 5th lowest in MLB; League Avg: .207.

The Pirates are just 108-54 (.667) when allowing 4 or fewer runs since last season — 3rd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .718.

The Pirates are just 96-21 (.821) when leading entering the 7th inning since last season — 5th lowest in MLB; League Avg: .870.

The Pirates are just 52-56 (.481) vs bottom 10 scoring offenses since last season — 5th lowest in MLB; League Avg: .573.

The Yankees are batting just .231 when facing the starting pitcher for the 3rd time in a game this season — lowest in MLB; League Avg: .267.

The Yankees are batting just .226 this season — 2nd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .249.

The Yankees are batting just .215 with two outs since last season — tied for lowest in MLB; League Avg: .237.

Yankees hitters are slugging .448 against LHP since last season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .408.

team hitters – home

Opponents have a line drive rate of just 21% against Yankees pitchers this season — lowest in MLB; League Avg: 23%.

Opponents have a groundball batting average of just .218 against Yankees pitchers with runners on base since last season — best in MLB; League Avg: .253.

Opponents have a groundball batting average of just .201 against Yankees pitchers with the shift this season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .241.

Yankees pitchers won 56% of games in which they allowed their opponent to score in three different innings at home in 2022 — highest in MLB; League Avg: 27%.

Pirates pitchers have walked 1,123 of 11,918 batters (9%) since last season — tied for 4th highest in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

The Pirates pitchers allowed their opponents to score first in 60% of their games on the road in 2022 — highest in MLB; League Avg: 46%.

Opponents have a groundball rate of 52% against Pirates pitchers over the past seven days (7 games) — 2nd highest in MLB; League Avg: 44%.

Pirates pitchers have allowed 157 home runs this season — fewest in MLB.

Pirates vs. Yankees Injuries Tonight That May Affect Prop Bets 

  • Andrew McCutchen (Pirates): Achilles, D10
  • Angel Perdomo (Pirates): Elbow, D60
  • Jarlín García (Pirates): Arm, D60
  • Vincent Velasquez (Pirates): Elbow, D60
  • Tucupita Marcano (Pirates): Knee, D60
  • Oneil Cruz (Pirates): Ankle, D60
  • Jonathan Brubaker (Pirates): Elbow, D60
  • Keynan Middleton (Yankees): Shoulder, D15
  • Jonathan Loáisiga (Yankees): Elbow, D15
  • Luis Severino (Yankees): Side, D15
  • Scott Effross (Yankees): Elbow, D60
  • James Weber (Yankees): Forearm, D60
  • Luis Gil (Yankees): Elbow, D60
  • Francelis Montas (Yankees): Shoulder, D60
  • Anthony Misiewicz (Yankees): Head, Day-to-Day
  • Albert Abreu (Yankees): Hamstring, D15
  • William McKinney (Yankees): Back, D10
  • Ian Hamilton (Yankees): Groin, D15
  • Jose Trevino (Yankees): Wrist, D60
  • Anthony Rizzo (Yankees): Concussion, D60
  • Nestor Cortes (Yankees): Shoulder, D60
  • Lou Trivino (Yankees): Elbow, D60
  • Jasson Domínguez (Yankees): Elbow, D10

Bet now on Yankees vs Pirates and all games with BetMGM


Bet on MLB Odds at BetMGM

At BetMGM, you can bet online with updated MLB betting odds. And with live sports betting, the best online sports betting and mobile sports betting (with the BetMGM Sportsbook app) experiences are at BetMGM.

BetMGM first bet offer for $1000
About the Author

BetMGM Betting

Read More @BETMGM

Our BetMGM betting authors are experts who focus on individual game matchups & player prop bets with an emphasis on betting odds, lines & predictions.

Our BetMGM betting authors are experts who focus on individual game matchups & player prop bets with an emphasis on betting odds, lines & predictions.