Josh Allen vs. Caleb Williams: Stats, Head-To-Head, MVP Odds

Josh Allen and Caleb Williams have established themselves as two of the NFL’s premier passers since entering the league, with Allen joining in 2018 and Williams arriving in 2024.

Both have racked up individual accolades, impressive statistics, and dozens of big-time wins, but they each bring different records and elements to the “Who’s better?” discussion.

• Josh Allen: The 2024 MVP and two-time All-Pro has the most rushing touchdowns by a quarterback in NFL history and highest passer rating in a single postseason.
• Caleb Williams: The 2022 Heisman Trophy recipient set the record for the most consecutive passing attempts without an interception by a rookie in 2024.

Below is a data-driven comparison of Allen and Williams in their respective NFL careers. You can also find updated 2026-27 NFL MVP odds.

Career Stats: Passing & Rushing Breakdown

Here’s a side-by-side look at career regular-season stats for each quarterback:

2026-27 NFL MVP Odds

Josh Allen’s MVP odds are +650. Caleb Williams’ MVP odds are +1500.

Here’s a look at players with the shortest odds:

FAQs: Josh Allen vs. Caleb Williams

Question: Has Josh Allen or Caleb Williams won more MVPs?
Answer: Allen has won one MVP (2024), while Williams has won none.

Question: Has Josh Allen or Caleb Williams won more Super Bowls?
Answer: Neither quarterback has won a Super Bowl.

Question: Does Josh Allen or Caleb Williams have more Pro Bowl selections?
Answer: Allen has four Pro Bowl selections while Williams has zero.

Question: Did Josh Allen or Caleb Williams get picked higher in the NFL Draft?
Answer: Both quarterbacks were drafted first overall in their respective drafts.

Question: Is Josh Allen or Caleb Williams older?
Answer: Allen is older (born May 21, 1996) than Williams (born Nov. 18, 2001).

Visit the sportsbook to bet on award odds, player props, and more NFL betting markets for Allen and Williams. You can also bet on Bills odds and Bears odds throughout the year.