NFL Week 5 Picks 2026: Bets Include Cowboys, Browns

Get my NFL expert picks for Week 5 of the 2026 NFL season, including a moneyline bet for Jets vs Browns on Sunday.

Below, bettors can find my NFL betting predictions for Week 5 based on NFL odds at BetMGM.

Odds for predictions are reflective at time of writing and are subject to movement.

NFL Week 5 Expert Picks 2026

Cowboys vs Buccaneers Prediction: Cowboys Spread (-9.5, -110)

Based on the Cowboys’ offensive power and an uncertainty around Tampa Bay’s ability to keep pace, my Cowboys vs Buccaneers prediction is the Cowboys Spread (-9.5, -110).

I came away more optimistic than not on the Buccaneers after Week 4’s showing. Tampa Bay covered all numbers except the close (+2.5) at home against Green Bay.

On offense, the Bucs moved the ball rather well on Green Bay’s defense. The unit averaged 4.5 yards per play and yards per rush, but it came undone by turnovers.

My worry for Thursday’s game: Can Tampa Bay keep up with a backup quarterback against a significantly better offense?

Dallas scored 30 or more in three straight games. The successes came against Washington (bad), Baltimore (better) and Houston (best).

CeeDee Lamb caught 17 passes for 189 yards in Houston. By contrast, he’ll face a much easier matchup against an injured Buccaneers secondary on short rest.

Jalon Daniels goes from playing in a game with a low total (39) to a higher benchmark (47.5 at open).

If that weren’t enough, the onus will presumably be on Daniels to stay within striking distance. On Sunday, the Cowboys defense allowed Houston to move the ball primarily through the air.

Houston averaged 7.6 yards per play – 10.2 yards per pass and 3.3 yards per rush. C.J. Stroud threw for 347 yards, 118 of which went to Nico Collins.

Daniels failed to properly exploit a bad Green Bay secondary on Sunday. It leaves me questioning how he’ll turn it around on short rest.

With this line sitting just beneath a key number, I predict the Cowboys cover the spread on Thursday.

Titans vs Texans Prediction: Titans Team Total Under 14.5 Points (-118)

Based on Houston’s difficult defensive schedule and Cam Ward’s poor offensive record against the Texans, my Titans vs Texans prediction is the Titans Under 14.5 Points (-118).

If this isn’t the best of buy-low spots on the Texans defense, I’m not sure it ever arrives.

Houston has yet to keep an opponent under this benchmark this season. The closest the defense came? Week 3 against the Colts, who scored 19 points.

Over four games, Houston faced only top-half offenses by 2025 offensive DVOA ratings. The team finally gets a reprieve this week against a bad Titans offense.

Tennessee cleared this benchmark in two of the last three. However, the unit fails to generate much offense until the opponent establishes a decent lead.

In the last two games, Tennessee scored two fourth-quarter touchdowns to make games closer than they seemed. Against the Ravens, Wan’Dale Robinson scored with 1:33 left.

Week 2’s 20-point performance is extremely misleading, too. The Titans scored a touchdown after intercepting Jalen Hurts in a goal-to-go situation for a 95-yard return.

Last year, Ward struggled to lead competent performances against Houston. Tennessee scored zero points on the road in Week 4 before reaching only 13 at home.

At home, Tennessee’s lone touchdown came in fourth-quarter garbage time. It leads me to predict Houston delivers its best defensive performance of the season in Week 5.

Packers vs Bears Prediction: Green Bay Packers Over 20.5 Points (-145)

Based on Green Bay’s ability to move the ball against Tampa Bay and the Bears’ misleading defensive record, my Packers vs Bears prediction is the Packers Over 20.5 Points (-145). 

I left Week 4 somewhat encouraged by the Packers offense. Against a decent Tampa Bay defense, Matt LaFleur’s offense posted a 47.4% offensive success rate (11th of 30).

Jordan Love continued to dominate through the air. As a team, Green Bay recorded a 51.5% dropback success rate, up from a 41.8% dropback success rate against Atlanta.

The offense scored only 17 points, but it fumbled at the Bucs’ three-yard line late.

Green Bay still ranks 28th in offensive DVOA through four games. However, it must go acknowledged that they’ve played the fifth-hardest set of defenses entering Week 5.

Only in the last two weeks, Chicago looks like a defensive juggernaut. Dennis Allen’s unit held the Eagles to seven points on MNF before limiting the Jets offense to 12 points.

On closer inspection, those performances don’t match Chicago’s points allowed. Particularly concerning is the Bears’ defensive performance against the Eagles.

Philadelphia notched two red zone chances against the Eagles. Andy Dalton, in place of Jalen Hurts, threw an interception in the end zone.

New York also recorded two red zone chances, failing to score a touchdown in the process.

Maybe it sounds a little insane, but I rate the Packers offense ahead of both Philly and New York. Plus, it’s the first road game for Chicago since Week 1, when they allowed 37 points.

A world exists where the Bears’ defensive voodoo continues on the road.

But I enter the game more optimistic than the market on Green Bay, which cleared this line twice in three tries against Chicago.

With the Packers’ team total sitting just beneath a key number, I predict the hosts clear a low number against a bad defense.

Jets vs Browns Moneyline: Cleveland Browns Moneyline (+110)

Based on Cleveland’s extra rest for Sunday’s game and New York’s lack of defensive strength, my Jets vs Browns prediction is the Browns Moneyline (+110).

Are we 100% sure the right team is favored in the opening odds? Cleveland, at 3-1, arrives at Sunday’s game with some momentum after a win on Thursday against the Steelers.

That immediately gives Todd Monken’s team a rest advantage for Sunday’s game.

Historically, it has proven a profitable spot for teams playing on a mini bye. Since 2015, road dogs with 10 days between games in game 5 onward are 51-31-1 ATS, including 41-25 at a +3 rest edge.

Beyond the trend, Cleveland’s defense leaves me inspired against a presumably Breece Hall-less Jets offense.

New York has shown zero ability to run the ball, even with Hall available. Excluding Week 4, Frank Reich’s offense ranks eighth in pass offense DVOA vs 20th in rush offense.

On defense, Cleveland ranks 17th in pass defense vs 22nd in rush defense, excluding Pittsburgh’s visit. Most of Cleveland’s pass rating stems from Week 1 at Jacksonville.

The defense posted three straight above-average games against the pass. Plus, the offense gets a tired Jets defense that played 89 snaps in Chicago.

It leads me to predict the Browns earn a third straight win against a bad team.

Steelers vs Colts Prediction: Pittsburgh Steelers Moneyline (-140)

Based on Indy’s misleading performance against the Commanders in London and Pittsburgh’s strong rushing attack, my Steelers vs Colts prediction is the Steelers Moneyline (-140).

This is the classic buy-low, sell-high opportunity.

Arguably no team looked better than the Colts as a 4.5-point favorite against the Commanders in London. Indianapolis won 30-13 in a game where the margin flattered the favorites.

Yards per play finished 5.2-3.9 in Washington’s direction. Most concerning for the Colts is a 3.6 yards per pass against one of the worst secondaries in the league.

Incredibly, the Colts won despite losing the turnover battle. Washington committed 10 penalties and failed twice from the red zone.

Then there’s Pittsburgh, which lost as a road favorite in Cleveland last Thursday. It leaves Mike McCarthy’s side beginning the game with a sizable rest advantage over the Colts.

What leaves me encouraged about the Steelers is how well they’ve run the ball.

Over the previous two games, Pittsburgh ranks fourth in rushing expected points added per play and eighth in rushing success rate (garbage time filtered out).

For the entire season, Pittsburgh ranks eighth in the percentage of runs that reached the second level and fifth in the percentage of runs that reached the open field, per FTN Fantasy.

In Week 5, they get a Colts defense that has struggled to put offenses under pressure. Currently, Indy’s 5.6% havoc rate ranks dead last in the NFL.

The Steelers, meanwhile, rank third and caused Daniel Jones to implode last year in Pittsburgh.

Nothing has changed about either team’s trenches, so I trust the Steelers to make Jones uncomfortable. It leads me to predict the Steelers will bounce back with a victory on Sunday.

Rams vs Bills Prediction: Rams Spread (-3, -108)

Based on the Rams’ sizable offensive advantage and the Bills’ offensive injuries, my Rams vs Bills prediction is the Los Angeles Rams Spread (-3, -108).

When two elite teams face off, you almost need to focus on the largest weakness on both sides. For me, the worst unit on the field Monday will be the Buffalo Bills defense.

Go ahead and slander the Rams’ special teams miscues all you want. In reality, I trust the Rams offense to move the ball on a bad defense that has largely faced poor opposition.

Buffalo ranks 27th in pass defense DVOA through four games, per FTN Fantasy. Only once all season – Week 3 against the Chargers – have the Bills posted an above-average pass defense rating.

The Rams sit 14th in pass offense DVOA entering Week 4. However, the unit operated without Puka Nacua for two games and performed better with him against Philadelphia.

On plays excluding turnovers, Los Angeles ranked eighth in dropback success rate at Philadelphia. Week over week, the Rams’ dropback success rate went from 44.2% at Denver to 55.4% at the Eagles.

Now Sean McVay gets a defense likely missing Christian Benford at cornerback. Without him, I question how the Bills defense gets stops against one of the league’s best aerial attacks.

Conversely, I worry about Josh Allen’s viability as an underdog in a negative game state. D.J. Moore remains hurt, and the other skill players have regressed since Week 2.

Forcing the Bills to rely on the passing game is, in my estimation, a winning strategy. Recently, the Bills offense delivered inferior passing metrics.

In Buffalo’s first two games, the offense recorded a 93.8% pass offense DVOA rating. Against the Chargers and Patriots, Buffalo recorded a -3.5% rating.

Given that drop-off, I predict the Rams win and cover due to Buffalo’s defensive inefficiencies.

NFL Picks Against the Spread: Week 5 Public Consensus

Get up-to-date NFL public betting data on all Week 5 games for both bets placed and money wagered percentages.

The content provided in this blog is intended for entertainment purposes only. All views and opinions expressed are the authors and reflect their individual perspectives on sports, betting, and related topics. This content should not be considered professional betting advice or the official views of BetMGM LLC. Please gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know is experiencing issues related to gambling, seek help from a licensed health professional. This blog is not liable for any losses, damages, or consequences resulting from betting activities.

About the Author Read More @nickhennion

Nick Hennion is a senior content writer for BetMGM. His previous stops include VSiN, NBC Sports, The Action Network and Forbes Betting. He owns a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University and a master's degree from Northwestern University.

Nick Hennion is a senior content writer for BetMGM. His previous stops include VSiN, NBC Sports, The Action Network and Forbes Betting. He owns a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University and a master's degree from Northwestern University.