Yankees vs Guardians Prediction, Odds & Player Prop Bets Today – MLB, Oct 19

Cleveland Guardians' Josh Naylor runs the base path during a spring training baseball game against the San Diego Padres, Monday, Feb. 26, 2024, in Peoria, Ariz.
(AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
  • The Yankees are -120 favorites vs the Guardians
  • Yankees vs Guardians Over / Under today: 7.5 Runs
  • Yankees / Guardians TV Channel: TBS | truT | Max

The New York Yankees (-120) visit Progressive Field to take on the Cleveland Guardians (+100) on Saturday, October 19, 2024. First pitch is scheduled for 8:08pm EDT in Cleveland, OH.

This season, the Yankees are 100-70 against the spread (ATS), while the Guardians are 85-85 ATS.

Yankees vs Guardians Starting Pitchers Today:

  • Yankees starting pitcher: Carlos Rodon 17-10, 3.92 ERA
  • Guardians starting pitcher: Tanner Bibee 12-9, 3.50 ERA

Yankees vs. Guardians Odds, Run Line, Over/Under & Moneyline

SpreadOver / UnderMoneyline
Yankees-1.5 +145O 7.5 -120-120
Guardians +1.5 -175U 7.5 +100+100

Yankees vs Guardians Prediction for Today’s Game

Based on recent trends the model predicts the Yankees will win Saturday‘s MLB game with 53.3% confidence, factoring in game simulations, recent player performances, starting pitchers and injuries.


Bet now on Yankees vs Guardians and all games with BetMGM


We’ve highlighted some favorite MLB player prop bets for Yankees players for Saturday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Yankees Player Prop Bets Today:

  • Jose Trevino has hit the Singles Under in 29 of his last 37 games (+17.35 Units / 35% ROI)
  • Jose Trevino has hit the Hits Under in 23 of his last 37 games (+14.95 Units / 39% ROI)
  • Jose Trevino has hit the Hits Runs and RBIs Under in 27 of his last 38 games (+14.20 Units / 28% ROI)
  • Giancarlo Stanton has hit the Home Runs Over in 4 of his last 6 games (+12.05 Units / 201% ROI)
  • Jose Trevino has hit the Total Bases Under in 23 of his last 37 games (+11.40 Units / 27% ROI)

And here are some favorite MLB player prop bets for Guardians players for Saturday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Guardians Player Prop Best Bets Today:

  • Lane Thomas has hit the Home Runs Over in 9 of his last 31 games (+29.80 Units / 96% ROI)
  • Bo Naylor has hit the Hits Runs and RBIs Under in 19 of his last 23 games (+15.15 Units / 55% ROI)
  • Josh Naylor has hit the Runs Under in 33 of his last 46 games (+12.75 Units / 16% ROI)
  • Lane Thomas has hit the Hits Over in 26 of his last 36 games (+9.90 Units / 15% ROI)
  • Lane Thomas has hit the Singles Under in 14 of his last 17 games at home (+9.20 Units / 33% ROI)
  • The New York Yankees have hit the Game Total Over in 67 of their last 113 games (+20.30 Units / 16% ROI)
  • The New York Yankees have covered the Run Line in 51 of their last 85 away games (+19.45 Units / 18% ROI)
  • The New York Yankees have hit the Team Total Under in 17 of their last 25 away games (+8.60 Units / 30% ROI)
  • The New York Yankees have hit the Moneyline in 53 of their last 85 away games (+8.30 Units / 7% ROI)
  • The New York Yankees have hit the 1st Five Innings (F5) Moneyline in 8 of their last 13 away games (+4.05 Units / 22% ROI)
  • The Cleveland Guardians have hit the Game Total Under in 46 of their last 78 games (+16.00 Units / 19% ROI)
  • The Cleveland Guardians have covered the Run Line in 41 of their last 81 games at home (+11.65 Units / 13% ROI)
  • The Cleveland Guardians have hit the Moneyline in 51 of their last 80 games at home (+11.10 Units / 10% ROI)
  • The Cleveland Guardians have hit the 1st Five Innings (F5) Team Total Over in 5 of their last 6 games at home (+4.75 Units / 68% ROI)
  • The Cleveland Guardians have covered the 1st Five Innings (F5) Run Line in 6 of their last 9 games at home (+2.60 Units / 24% ROI)

Yankees Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this season, the Yankees are 88-82 against the Run Line (+11.4 Units / 5.64% ROI).

  • 100-70 when betting on the Moneyline for -9.35 Units / -3.47% ROI
  • 90-74 when betting on the total runs Over for +8.15 Units / 4.34% ROI
  • 74-90 when betting on the total runs Under for -24.8 Units / -13.28% ROI

Guardians Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this season, the Guardians are 85-85 against the Run Line (+1.25 Units / 0.58% ROI).

  • 96-74 when betting on the Moneyline for +9.55 Units / 4.35% ROI
  • 74-85 when betting on the total runs Over for -19.55 Units / -10.45% ROI
  • 85-74 when betting on the total runs Under for +3.35 Units / 1.79% ROI

Guardians vs Yankees Home Run Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Aaron Judge (NYY) 0.5 +280 0.5 -350
Giancarlo Stanton (NYY) 0.5 +350 0.5 -450
Jose Ramirez (CLE) 0.5 +425 0.5 -600
Juan Soto (NYY) 0.5 +450 0.5 -650
Jhonkensy Noel (CLE) 0.5 +575 0.5 -900

Guardians vs Yankees Total Hits Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Steven Kwan (CLE) 0.5 -250 0.5 +175
Gleyber Torres (NYY) 0.5 -250 0.5 +185
Jose Ramirez (CLE) 0.5 -225 0.5 +175
Juan Soto (NYY) 0.5 -190 0.5 +145
Aaron Judge (NYY) 0.5 -190 0.5 +140

Guardians vs Yankees RBI Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Aaron Judge (NYY) 0.5 +140 0.5 -190
Giancarlo Stanton (NYY) 0.5 +145 0.5 -190
Jose Ramirez (CLE) 0.5 +160 0.5 -225
Jazz Chisholm Jr (NYY) 0.5 +170 0.5 -225
Juan Soto (NYY) 0.5 +190 0.5 -250

Guardians vs Yankees Strikeout Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Tanner Bibee (CLE) 3.5 -150 3.5 +110
Carlos Rodon (NYY) 5.5 -110 5.5 -120

Carlos Rodon had an ERA of 6.48 (50.0 IP) against division opponents in the 2024 season — highest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 3.56 — first Percentile.

Right-handed hitters had a groundball rate of just 33% (129/387) against Carlos Rodon in the 2024 season — lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 44% — first Percentile.

Opponents had a groundball rate of just 35% (165/474) against Carlos Rodon in the 2024 season — 4th lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 43% — sixth Percentile.

Opponents had a groundball rate of just 37% (78/211) against Carlos Rodon in two-strike counts in the 2024 season — 3rd lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 45% — sixth Percentile.

Guardians Starting Pitcher Stats & Trends

The average home run distance against Tanner Bibee in the 2023 season was 379.5 feet — best in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 64 total IP; League Avg: 399.3

Tanner Bibee allowed a slugging percentage of .439 (112 Total Bases / 255 ABs) when going through the lineup the second time in a game in the 2024 season — 10th highest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: .382 — 16th Percentile.

Opponents batted .398 (35-for-88) against Tanner Bibee on the first pitch of at-bats in the 2024 season — 6th highest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: .330 — 11th Percentile.

The average home run distance against Tanner Bibee since last season is 383.8 feet — 3rd best in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 129 total IP; League Avg: 398.5

Yankees Keys to the Game vs. the Guardians

The Yankees are 79-23 (.775) when they’ve scored in the first inning since the 2023 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .626.

The Yankees are 122-36 (.772) when they’ve scored in the first inning since the 2022 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .638.

The Yankees are 150-11 (.932) when leading entering the 8th inning since the 2023 season — tied for 4th best in MLB; League Avg: .899.

The Yankees are 140-14 (.909) when leading entering the 7th inning since the 2023 season — 4th best in MLB; League Avg: .858.

Guardians Keys to the Game vs. the Yankees

The Guardians are 40-174 (.187) when trailing entering the 7th inning since the 2022 season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .134.

The Guardians are 147-4 (.974) when leading entering the 9th inning since the 2023 season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .949.

The Guardians are 65-9 (.878) when they’ve had 5 or more XBH since the 2022 season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .801.

The Guardians are 90-26 (.776) when they’ve hit 2 or more home runs since the 2022 season — 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: .702.

Yankees hitters drew 221 walks in 1,808 PA’s (12%) against LHP in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Yankees hitters have drawn 333 walks in 2,976 PA’s (11%) against LHP since last season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Yankees hitters have drawn 495 walks in 4,525 PA’s (11%) against LHP since the 2022 season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Yankees hitters drew 672 walks in 6,245 PA’s (11%) in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Guardians hitters have put just 34% of balls in play to the left side of the field since last season — lowest in MLB; League Avg: 38%.

Guardians hitters have put just 35% of balls in play to the left side of the field since the 2022 season — lowest in MLB; League Avg: 38%.

Guardians hitters have just 2,444 strikeouts in 13,061 PA’s (19%) against RHP since the 2022 season — best in MLB; League Avg: 23%.

Guardians hitters have just 1,649 strikeouts in 8,477 PA’s (20%) against RHP since last season — 2nd best in MLB; League Avg: 23%.

Opponents have a groundball batting average of just .210 against Yankees pitchers with the shift since the 2022 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .236.

Opponents have a miss rate of 27% against Yankees pitchers since the 2022 season — tied for 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: 26%.

Yankees pitchers have a strikeout rate of 24% with runners in scoring position since last season — tied for 3rd best in MLB; League Avg: 22%.

The Yankees pitchers allowed division opponents to score first in 65% of their games in the 2023 season — highest in MLB; League Avg: 50%.

Opponents had a groundball batting average of just .207 against Guardians pitchers with runners on base in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .262.

Opponents had a groundball batting average of just .223 against Guardians pitchers in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .249.

The Guardians allowed 0.87 runs per game (140/161) in late innings in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: 1.29.

Opponents have a groundball batting average of just .228 against Guardians pitchers with runners on base since last season — best in MLB; League Avg: .260.

Guardians vs. Yankees Injuries Tonight That May Affect Prop Bets 

  • Cleveland Guardians – No Injuries Reported
  • New York Yankees – No Injuries Reported

Bet now on Yankees vs Guardians and all games with BetMGM


Bet on MLB Odds at BetMGM

Sportsbook promos are always available at BetMGM. For new customers, check out the sportsbook welcome offer and BetMGM Refer a Friend. For existing customers, there are Odds Boosts, Parlay Boosts, contests and more.

First Bet Offer BetMGM State Promo Pages $1,500
About the Author

Shane Jackson

Read More @Sjacksonmgm

Shane Jackson is a Web Content Writer for BetMGM, covering MLB and NBA. After graduating from the University of Kansas, his previous stops include MLB.com, Lawrence Journal-World, Manhattan Mercury, Bet Chicago Sports, WynnBET, and Sportsbook Review.

Shane Jackson is a Web Content Writer for BetMGM, covering MLB and NBA. After graduating from the University of Kansas, his previous stops include MLB.com, Lawrence Journal-World, Manhattan Mercury, Bet Chicago Sports, WynnBET, and Sportsbook Review.