2022 College Football Hot Seat, Buyouts, & Replacements

min read
Texas A&M head coach Jimbo Fisher calls plays against Massachusetts during the first quarter of an NCAA college football game Saturday, Nov. 19, 2022, in College Station, Texas. (AP Photo/Sam Craft)
(AP Photo/Sam Craft)
Andrew Doughty @DoughtyBetMGM Nov 26, 2022, 9:50 AM
  • Only four coaches are on the hot seat entering Week 13.
  • Jimbo Fisher's buyout isn't small.
  • Eight coaches have already been fired.

Twenty-nine college football programs have a first-year head coach in 2022. The largest single-season turnover in college football history included some forced changes – e.g., UAB’s Bill Clark retiring and Oklahoma’s Lincoln Riley leaving for USC – but was mostly the result of a hot seat that spared very few coaches failing to meet expectations.

Which coaches might be on the hot seat in 2022?

College Football Hot Seat for 2022

Neal Brown – West Virginia

Seconds after West Virginia’s loss to Kansas in Week 2, I tweeted, “Neal Brown = Hot Seat.”

Three minutes later, I retracted it, pointing to a massive buyout of approximately $16 million if Brown is fired after this season.

Six weeks later, I reversed course again; West Virginia is no 4-7, and Neal Brown should be on the hot seat.

After a loss to Kansas State in Week 12, the Mountaineers are 7-11 in the Big 12 since 2021 and 13-21 in conference games in four seasons under Brown. They’ve never won more than six games in a season or finished better than fifth in the conference.

Despite the buyout, it might be time for a change in Morgantown, as potentially signaled by the termination of athletics director Shane Lyons, who inexplicably gifted Brown an extension after the 2020 season.

Neal Brown Buyout: For unknown reasons, Lyons and West Virginia gave Brown with a contract extension in April 2021. The new deal includes a buyout equal to 100% of the remaining contract if fired before Dec. 31, 2024, which is approximately $16 million if fired after this season.

Neal Brown Replacement: West Virginia reportedly focused on three candidates after Dana Holgorsen’s departure in late 2018: Brown, then-defensive coordinator Tony Gibson, and Cincinnati head coach Luke Fickell. All three interviewed for the job.

Fickell is (presumably) out of reach, while Gibson – currently NC State defensive coordinator – could be a candidate again. Willie Fritz could make a short list, as could Kane Wommack, Mike Houston, and Jamey Chadwell.

Jimbo Fisher – Texas A&M

Texas A&M athletics director Ross Bjork claimed in September 2021 that Jimbo Fisher had Texas A&M on a path toward “championship-level success.”

Since that comment the Aggies have lost 11 of 23 games, including 10 of 15 SEC games, and become the biggest laughingstock in college football.

After a loss to Auburn in Week 10 and uninspiring win over lowly UMass in Week 11, the heat beneath Fisher’s overpaid booty likely increased. He’s paid an extreme amount of money to compete for national championships, not finish in the bottom half of the SEC West.

Jimbo Fisher Buyout: If fired, Jimbo Fisher’s buyout would be the largest in college football history. It’s currently approximately $90 million and doesn’t drop below $50 million until late in 2026.

 Jimbo Fisher Replacement: If Texas A&M’s donors are willing to pay a $90-million buyout, they’re presumably willing to pay big money for a replacement. What would it take to land Josh Heupel, Dave Aranda, or Shane Beamer? Could they interest Luke Fickell with a $100-million contract?

David Shaw – Stanford

Four years ago, this seemed incomprehensible as David Shaw’s job security presumably sat alongside Nick Saban and Dabo Swinney as the best in college football.

The former Cardinals receiver won 82 games in his first eight years as head coach, during which he won three conference championships (and two more division championships), lost only 17 conference games, and flirted with national championship contention. Over the last three years, he’s winning roughly one-third of games.

Shaw is the best coach in program history, has a top-30 (247Sports) recruiting class for 2022, and is only three years removed from a seventh nine-win season in eight years. But is another miserable season moving the needle in the wrong direction? 

David Shaw Buyout: Shaw’s entire contract has never been made publicly available, though he reportedly earned $8.9 million in 2019, which would suggest his deal includes an eight-figure buyout. 

David Shaw Replacement: I have no idea.

If he’s gone, it could be mutual and include a provision for Shaw’s assistance in the search. Perhaps they could persuade Dave Clawson to leave Wake Forest or Mike Elko to leave Duke? If not, others to consider: Jeff Monken, Troy Calhoun, or Blake Anderson.

Jake Spavital – Texas State

One year ago, Jake Spavital appeared to be building legitimate momentum at Texas State – something that’s happened only one other time in program history. The Bobcats won their regular-season finale to finish with four wins for the first time since 2014.

The momentum is now gone, as they limp through an eighth straight sub-.500 conference season. The recruiting classes are poor even by low-level Sun Belt standards, and they’re not getting enough returns from JUCO or FBS transfers.

Jake Spavital Buyout: Spavital is still coaching on the original five-year deal signed in late-November 2018 that runs through Nov. 27, 2023, and pays him $800,000 per year. If fired before the contract ends, he’s due 50% of the remaining guaranteed salary, which would be approximately $400,000 if fired after the 2022 season.

Jake Spavital Replacement: The Athletic surveyed athletics directors, coaches, and agents last year, asking them about the hardest jobs in college football. Texas State didn’t receive a single vote for top-5 hardest job, meaning it sat behind (at least) 22 other jobs, including three Sun Belt jobs: Georgia Southern, Old Dominion, and UL Monroe.

This isn’t a great job but it’s not an impossible job with zero interest from proven coaches.

Perhaps the administration could triple the salary pool to lure another proven Power Five coordinator like Garrett Riley, Graham Harrell, or Jeff Lebby.

If not – or alternatively – they could target a former Texas State assistant like Jason Washington (Mississippi State running backs coach) or Craig Naivar (SMU specials teams coach), or an FCS coach like K.C. Keeler (Sam Houston State), G. J. Kinne (Incarnate Word), or Colby Carthel (Stephen F. Austin).

College Football Odds at BetMGM

Online betting is a unique way to take your college football entertainment to the next level this season.

With updated spreads, over/under totals, live betting odds, and more for hundreds of FBS and FCS games from August through the College Football Playoff in January, there’s never a break in the action.

Check out the BetMGM sportsbook on jam-packed Saturdays to place your live bets on college football odds!

Jamie Foxx holding a mobile phone next to the BetMGM's risk-free bet offer.
About the Author

Andrew Doughty

Read More @DoughtyBetMGM

Andrew Doughty is a writer for BetMGM with a focus on college football, NFL, college basketball, and NASCAR. A graduate of the University of Kansas, he previously wrote for Sports Illustrated and HERO Sports.

Andrew Doughty is a writer for BetMGM with a focus on college football, NFL, college basketball, and NASCAR. A graduate of the University of Kansas, he previously wrote for Sports Illustrated and HERO Sports.