Yankees vs Athletics Prediction, Odds & Player Prop Bets Today – MLB, May 9

Oakland Athletics' Brent Rooker scores on a double by Aledmys Diaz off Pittsburgh Pirates relief pitcher Rob Zastryzny during the eighth inning of a baseball game in Pittsburgh, Monday, June 5, 2023.
(AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)
  • The Yankees are -150 favorites vs the Athletics
  • Yankees vs Athletics Over / Under today: 10.5 Runs
  • Yankees / Athletics TV Channel: YES | NSCA | MLBN

The New York Yankees (-150) visit Sutter Health Park to take on the Oakland Athletics (+125) on Friday, May 9, 2025. First pitch is scheduled for 10:05pm EDT in Sacramento, CA, CA.

This season, the Yankees are 21-16 against the spread (ATS), while the Athletics are ATS.

Yankees vs Athletics Starting Pitchers Today:

  • Yankees starting pitcher: Will Warren 1-2, 5.66 ERA
  • Athletics starting pitcher: Osvaldo Bido 2-2, 4.75 ERA

Yankees vs. Athletics Odds, Run Line, Over/Under & Moneyline

SpreadOver / UnderMoneyline
Yankees-1.5 +105O 10.5 -105-150
Athletics +1.5 -125U 10.5 -115+125

Yankees vs Athletics Prediction for Today’s Game

Based on recent trends the model predicts the Yankees will win Friday‘s MLB game with 57.2% confidence, factoring in game simulations, recent player performances, starting pitchers and injuries.


Bet now on Yankees vs Athletics and all games with BetMGM


We’ve highlighted some favorite MLB player prop bets for Yankees players for Friday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Yankees Player Prop Bets Today:

And here are some favorite MLB player prop bets for Athletics players for Friday‘s game, looking at profitable historical betting trends:

Best Athletics Player Prop Best Bets Today:

Yankees Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this season, the Yankees are 18-19 against the Run Line (+0.95 Units / 2.33% ROI).

  • 21-16 when betting on the Moneyline for -0.55 Units / -0.99% ROI
  • 16-19 when betting on the total runs Over for -4.75 Units / -11.74% ROI
  • 19-16 when betting on the total runs Under for +1.32 Units / 3.23% ROI

Athletics Against the Spread (ATS) Record

Against the spread this season, the Athletics are against the Run Line ( Units / ROI).

  • home moneyline record when betting on the Moneyline for ML units Units / ML ROI ROI
  • home total over record when betting on the total runs Over for over units Units / over ROI ROI
  • home total under record when betting on the total runs Under for under units Units / under ROI ROI

Athletics vs Yankees Home Run Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Aaron Judge (NYY) 0.5 +160 0.5 -200
Brent Rooker (ATH) 0.5 +310 0.5 -400
Trent Grisham (NYY) 0.5 +310 0.5 -400
Shea Langeliers (ATH) 0.5 +325 0.5 -450
Austin Wells (NYY) 0.5 +325 0.5 -450

Athletics vs Yankees Total Hits Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Miguel Andujar (ATH) 0.5 -275 0.5 +195
Paul Goldschmidt (NYY) 0.5 -250 0.5 +195
Tyler Soderstrom (ATH) 0.5 -235 0.5 +175
Brent Rooker (ATH) 0.5 -225 0.5 +170
Ben Rice (NYY) 0.5 -220 0.5 +165

Athletics vs Yankees RBI Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Aaron Judge (NYY) 0.5 -105 0.5 -120
Austin Wells (NYY) 0.5 +140 0.5 -190
Ben Rice (NYY) 0.5 +140 0.5 -185
Paul Goldschmidt (NYY) 0.5 +145 0.5 -190
Shea Langeliers (ATH) 0.5 +155 0.5 -210

Athletics vs Yankees Strikeout Prop Bets Today

Over Under
Will Warren (NYY) 4.5 +100 4.5 -130
Osvaldo Bido (ATH) 4.5 +145 4.5 -190

Hitters have swung at 50% of Will Warren’s pitches (95/190) with two-strikes this season — 2nd lowest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 14 total IP; League Avg: 59% — first Percentile.

Hitters have swung at 39% of Will Warren’s pitches (220/572) this season — 2nd lowest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 14 total IP; League Avg: 47% — first Percentile.

Opponents have a swing rate of just 33% (125/382) against Will Warren in non-two strike counts this season — lowest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 14 total IP; League Avg: 42% — 0 Percentile.

Will Warren has allowed three-ball counts to 30% of batters they faced (40/131 PA’s) this season — 2nd highest in MLB among starting pitchers with at least 14 total IP; League Avg: 20% — first Percentile.

Athletics Starting Pitcher Stats & Trends

Left-handed hitters have a groundball rate of just 21% (10/47) against Osvaldo Bido this season — 2nd lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 42% — third Percentile.

Osvaldo Bido has struck out just 7% (7/93) of right-handed batters he faced this season — lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 22% — first Percentile.

Right-handed batters are hitting .329 (27-for-82) against Osvaldo Bido this season — 2nd highest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: .234 — second Percentile.

Osvaldo Bido has a strikeout rate of just 13% (21 SO in 160 PAs) this season — 4th lowest among qualified SPs in MLB; League Avg: 22% — fourth Percentile.

Yankees Keys to the Game vs. the Athletics

The Yankees were 37-21 (.638) vs the top 10 runs allowed teams in the 2024 season They play the Tigers (fifth best runs allowed) today.

The Yankees were 48-10 (.828) when they scored in the first inning in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .641.

The Yankees are 48-29 (.623) vs the top 10 runs allowed teams since last season They play the Athletics (24th best runs allowed) today.

The Yankees are 89-29 (.754) when they’ve scored in the first inning since the 2023 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .624.

Athletics Keys to the Game vs. the Yankees

The Athletics are just 35-88 (.285) vs top 10 scoring offenses since the 2023 season They play the Yankees (third best runs scored) today.

The Athletics are just 71-109 (.394) at home since the 2023 season — 2nd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .527.

The Athletics are just 83-137 (.377) after a loss since the 2023 season — 3rd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .494.

The Athletics were just 4-8 (.308) when tied entering the 7th inning in the 2024 season — tied for 2nd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .498.

Yankees hitters have drawn walks in 12% of its PA’s against LHP since last season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Yankees hitters drew 221 walks in 1,808 PA’s (12%) against LHP in the 2024 season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Yankees hitters have a swing rate of just 44% against LHP since last season — lowest in MLB; League Avg: 48%.

Yankees hitters have drawn walks in 12% of its PA’s when facing the starting pitcher for the 3rd time in a game since last season — best in MLB; League Avg: 8%.

Athletics hitters are averaging just 3.54 pitches per plate appearance against LHP this season — lowest in MLB; League Avg: 3.89.

The Athletics batted just .200 with two outs in 2023 — lowest in MLB; League Avg: .237.

Athletics hitters had an OPS of just .673 (1,648 PA’s) against LHP in the 2023 season — 2nd lowest in MLB; League Avg: .742.

The Athletics batted just .216 at home in 2023 — lowest in MLB; League Avg: .252.

Opponents had a groundball batting average of just .214 against Yankees pitchers with runners on base in 2023 — best in MLB; League Avg: .259.

Opponents have a groundball batting average of just .233 against Yankees pitchers with runners on base since the 2023 season — best in MLB; League Avg: .261.

Yankees pitchers have walked 10% of batters this season — 2nd highest in MLB; League Avg: 9%.

Yankees pitchers have a strikeout rate of 25% this season — 5th best in MLB; League Avg: 22%.

Athletics pitchers walked 694 of 6,384 batters (11%) in 2023 — highest in MLB; League Avg: 9%.

Opponents had a groundball rate of just 38% against Athletics pitchers in 2023 — lowest in MLB; League Avg: 43%.

Athletics pitchers had an ERA of 6.09 (676.2 IP) on the road in 2023 — highest in MLB; League Avg: 4.44.

Opponents have a groundball rate of just 40% against Athletics pitchers since the 2023 season — 2nd lowest in MLB; League Avg: 43%.

More MLB Reading:


Bet now on Yankees vs Athletics and all games with BetMGM


Bet on MLB Odds at BetMGM

Sportsbook promos are always available at BetMGM. For new customers, check out the sportsbook welcome offer and BetMGM Refer a Friend. For existing customers, there are Odds Boosts, Parlay Boosts, contests and more.

Split First Bet Offer FBO March Matchups 1080x610
About the Author

BetMGM Betting

Read More @BETMGM

Our BetMGM betting authors are experts who focus on individual game matchups & player prop bets with an emphasis on betting odds, lines & predictions.

Our BetMGM betting authors are experts who focus on individual game matchups & player prop bets with an emphasis on betting odds, lines & predictions.