Manchester United vs. Sheffield United Prediction, Odds, Pick | Premier League Match Preview

Manchester United's Bruno Fernandes, celebrates after scoring the opening goal with a penalty kick during an English Premier League soccer match between Manchester United and Everton at the Old Trafford stadium in Manchester, England, Saturday, March 9, 2024.
(AP Photo/Dave Thompson)
  • Manchester United is a -1.5-goal favorite against Sheffield United.
  • The Red Devils earned a 2-1 road win against Sheffield in the last meeting.
  • Why the market is overvaluing Manchester United as home favorites.

Following their FA Cup semifinal win against Coventry City on Sunday, Manchester United return home to face Premier League cellar-dwellers Sheffield United.ย 

The Red Devils needed penalty kicks to reach the FA Cup final after blowing a 3-0 advantage late in the second half.ย 

As for Sheffield United, they struggled at home against relegation-threatened Burnley. As short home dogs, they fell 4-1 to the Clarets.ย 

Hereโ€™s a look at the EPL odds and my prediction for Wednesdayโ€™s match.ย 

EPL Betting Odds – Manchester United vs. Sheffield United

  • Manchester United Moneyline: -350
  • Sheffield United Moneyline: +750
  • Draw Moneyline: +500
  • Over/Under: 3.5 Goals (-120/-120)

EPL Prediction – Manchester United vs. Sheffield United

Sheffield United Spread (+1.5, +100)

If bettors learned anything from Unitedโ€™s FA Cup semifinal on Sunday, itโ€™s that the backdoor is always open.ย 

Up 3-0 on Championship side Coventry City, United surrendered three goals in the final 20 minutes + injury time to send the match to extra time.ย 

United also ran fairly lucky in that match as they lost the post-shot expected goals battle 1.55 to 2.23, per fotmob.com.ย 

Now they have to turn around and play on short rest. Although the odds suggest theyโ€™ll win the match outright, I question if they cover a lofty spread.ย 

Sample nine matches this season in which United closed at -145 or higher and bettors will find theyโ€™re 6-3 SU, but have seen five of those wins come by a single goal.ย 

Since the beginning of last season, theyโ€™re 16-7 SU at -145 or higher but have covered -1.5 in only seven of those 23 matches.ย 

Itโ€™s also not as if they dominated Sheffield United when they last played. United won the match 2-1 but only captured the non-penalty expected goals battle 1.1 to 0.63.ย 

Plus, thereโ€™s a historically profitable system recommending a bet on Sheffield United.ย 

Since 2012-13, road dogs with a win percentage under 30% are 63.7% ATS, assuming three factors:

  • The spread is between +1.5 and +2.5
  • The previous head-to-head result was between -1 and -5
  • The teamโ€™s game number is between 17 and 38

Just this season, those teams are 14-2-1 ATS.ย 

One final note with a slight caveat โ€“ history suggests Sheffield are worth a flier on the moneyline.ย 

Since 2012-13, road dogs between +355 and +2000 with a win percentage under 28% are 18.9% SU for a 45% return on investment, assuming two factors:

  • The previous head-to-head result was between -1 and +1
  • The teamโ€™s game number is between 18 and 38

However, Iโ€™m obliged to mention three teams have fit that profile after allowing two or more goals in seven straight games, a moniker that fits Sheffield.ย 

Those teams are 0-3 SU in such spots.ย 

As a result, Iโ€™d prefer to take a moneyline position on Burnley at Old Trafford on Saturday.ย 

That said, even money on Sheffield to stay within a goal is worth a wager on Wednesday.ย 

Manchester United Formย 

April 21 vs. Coventry City: 3-3, D (FA Cup, United Win on PKโ€™s)

April 13 at Bournemouth: 2-2, D

April 7 vs. Liverpool: 2-2, D

April 4 at Chelsea: 3-4, L

March 30 at Brentford: 1-1, D

Sheffield United Form

April 20 vs. Burnley: 1-4, L

April 13 vs. Brentford: 0-2, L

April 7 vs. Chelsea: 2-2, D

April 4 at Liverpool: 1-3, L

March 30 vs. Fulham: 3-3, D

Upcoming EPL Match Schedule

First Bet Offer $1,500 FBO
HomeAwayDateTime (ET)Location
EvertonWest Ham UnitedMar. 1511 a.m.Goodison Park
Ipswich TownNottingham ForestMar. 1511 a.m.The City Ground
Manchester CityBrightonMar. 1511 a.m.Etihad Stadium
SouthamptonWolvesMar. 1511 a.m.St. Mary's Stadium
BournemouthBrentfordMar. 151:30 p.m.Vitality Stadium
ArsenalChelseaMar. 169:30 a.m.Emirates Stadium
FulhamTottenhamMar. 169:30 a.m.Craven Cottage
Leicester CityManchester UnitedMar. 163 p.m.King Power Stadium

EPL Standings

TeamRecord (Wins-Draws-Losses)PointsGoal Differential
Liverpool21-7-17042
Arsenal15-10-35528
Nottingham Forest15-6-75112
Chelsea14-7-74917
Manchester City14-5-94715
Newcastle United14-5-9479
Brighton12-10-6466
Aston Villa12-9-845-4
Bournemouth12-8-84413
Fulham11-9-8423
Crystal Palace10-9-9393
Brentford11-5-12384
Tottenham10-4-143414
Manchester United9-7-1234-6
Everton7-12-933-4
West Ham9-6-1333-16
Wolves6-5-1723-19
Ipswich Town3-8-1717-32
Leicester City4-5-1917-37
Southampton2-3-239-48

EPL ATS Records

TeamATS RecordATS%Home ATS RecordHome ATS%Road ATS RecordRoad ATS%
Arsenal10-13-544.6%3-7-334.6%7-6-253.3%
Aston Villa11-17-140.0%5-9-136.7%6-8-042.9%
Bournemouth17-11-160.3%7-7-050.0%10-4-170.0%
Brentford17-10-262.1%8-7-053.3%9-3-271.4%
Brighton & Hove Albion17-11-160.3%7-7-059.0%10-4-170.0%
Chelsea10-16-239.3%5-8-139.3%5-8-139.3%
Crystal Palace16-9-362.5%6-6-350.0%10-3-076.9%
Everton15-10-458.6%7-6-253.3%8-4-264.3%
Fulham16-10-260.7%6-8-042.9%9-3-271.4%
Ipswich Town11-16-241.4%4-11-026.7%7-5-257.1%
Leicester City12-15-144.6%5-9-035.7%7-6-153.6%
Liverpool15-13-153.4%6-7-146.4%9-6-060.0%
Manchester City9-20-031.0%4-10-028.6%5-10-033.3%
Manchester United11-13-446.4%6-7-246.7%5-6-246.2%
Newcastle United15-12-155.4%8-5-061.5%7-7-150.0%
Nottingham Forest19-10-065.5%9-5-064.3%10-5-066.7%
Southampton10-16-339.7%2-11-117.9%8-5-260.0%
Tottenham Hotspur11-16-141.1%5-9-136.7%6-7-046.2%
West Ham United15-13-153.4%5-9-136.7%10-4-071.4%
Wolverhampton Wanderers13-13-350.0%5-7-242.9%8-6-156.7%
About the Author

Nick Hennion

Read More @nickhennion

Nick Hennion is a senior content writer for BetMGM. His previous stops include VSiN, NBC Sports, The Action Network and Forbes Betting. He owns a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University and a master's degree from Northwestern University.

Nick Hennion is a senior content writer for BetMGM. His previous stops include VSiN, NBC Sports, The Action Network and Forbes Betting. He owns a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University and a master's degree from Northwestern University.