NFL Betting: Each Quarterback’s Record Against the Spread

min read
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes looks to pass during the second half of an NFL football game against the Detroit Lions Thursday, Sept. 7, 2023, in Kansas City, Mo.
(AP Photo/Charlie Riedel)
Nick Hennion @nickhennion Jan 08, 2024, 4:46 PM
  • Patrick Mahomes’ outstanding record as an underdog.
  • Joe Burrow’s brilliant ATS record since joining the league.
  • Read on to get favorite & underdog records for all 32 starting quarterbacks.

When evaluating NFL odds, bettors should remember quarterbacks perform differently when they’re a favorite vs. an underdog.

This can equip bettors with an advantage and allow them to take advantage of certain spreads.  

Here, I’ll break down each starting quarterback’s record as a favorite and an underdog. All data comes courtesy of Bet Labs. 

NFL Quarterback Records Against the Spread (ATS)

Records reflective as of January 8, 2024. 

AFC Quarterbacks

 

QuarterbackATS RecordFavoriteUnderdog
Lamar Jackson43-34-0 (55.8%)31-33-0 (48.4%)12-1-0 (92.3%)
Josh Allen49-39-5 (55.4%)32-30-3 (51.5%)17-9-2 (64.3%)
Joe Burrow31-20-1 (60.6%)18-12-1 (59.7%)13-8-0 (61.9%)
Deshaun Watson32-30-2 (51.6%)13-17-2 (43.8%)19-13-0 (59.4%)
Russell Wilson93-88-7 (51.3%)57-69-5 (45.4%)36-19-2 (64.9%)
C.J. Stroud8-7-0 (53.3%)3-4-0 (42.9%)5-3-0 (62.5%)
Anthony Richardson3-2-0 (60%)1-0-0 (100%)2-2-0 (50%)
Trevor Lawrence21-29-0 (42%)7-10-0 (41.2%)14-19-0 (42.4%)
Patrick Mahomes48-45-3 (51.6%)41-44-2 (48.3%)7-1-1 (87.5%)
Jimmy Garoppolo35-27-1 (56.3%)20-21-1 (48.8%)15-6-0 (71.4%)
Justin Herbert32-28-2 (53.2%)19-19-1 (50%)13-9-1 (58.7%)
Tua Tagovailoa29-21-1 (57.8%)18-11-0 (62.1%)11-10-1 (52.3%)
Mac Jones16-25-1 (39.3%)12-10-1 (54.3%)4-15-0 (21.1%)
Zach Wilson14-18-1 (43.9%)2-2-1 (50%)12-16-0 (42.9%)
Kenny Pickett15-9-0 (62.5%)7-6-0 (53.8%)8-3-0 (72.7%)
Will Levis3-5-0 (37.5%)1-1-0 (50%)2-4-0 (33.3%)

NFC Quarterbacks

QuarterbackATS RecordFavoriteUnderdog
Desmond Ridder8-9-0 (47.1%)5-5-0 (50%)3-4-0 (42.9%)
Kyler Murray34-29-2 (53.8%)9-15-0 (37.5%)25-14-2 (63.4%)
Bryce Young5-11-1 (32.4%)0-0-0 (0%)5-11-1 (32.4%)
Justin Fields15-22-1 (40.8%)3-3-0 (50%)12-19-1 (39.1%)
Dak Prescott64-47-2 (57.5%)49-33-2 (59.5%)15-14-0 (51.7%)
Jared Goff66-48-3 (57.7%)39-29-3 (57%)27-19-0 (58.7%)
Jordan Love9-9-0 (50%)2-5-0 (28.6%)7-4-0 (63.6%)
Matthew Stafford93-107-6 (46.6%)49-55-3 (47.2%)44-52-3 (46%)
Kirk Cousins73-70-2 (51%)36-38-2 (48.7%)37-32-0 (53.6%)
Derek Carr75-80-3 (48.4%)20-36-2 (36.2%)55-44-1 (55.5%)
Daniel Jones31-27-0 (53.4%)5-8-0 (38.5%)26-19-0 (57.18%)
Jalen Hurts23-25-2 (48%)17-18-2 (48.6%)6-7-0 (46.2%)
Brock Purdy17-8-0 (68%)17-7-0 (70.8%)0-1-0 (0%)
Geno Smith32-31-3 (50.8%)10-15-1 (40.4%)22-16-2 (57.5%)
Baker Mayfield37-48-1 (43.6%)14-26-1 (35.4%)23-22-0 (51.1%)
Sam Howell7-11-0 (38.9%)0-4-0 (0%)7-7-0 (50%)

NFL Same Game Parlays

Parlays are a great way to take your NFL betting to the next level. And at the online sportsbook, you can build parlays with a single game.

Same Game Parlays allow bettors to add multiple bets within the same game to increase the excitement and potential payout. You can also combine Same Game Game Parlays with Same Game Parlay Plus (SGP+).

Sign in to your account today — or, if you don’t have an account, sign up today with a sportsbook welcome bonus — to start betting. And don’t forget to check updated sportsbook bonuses and promos each day of the year.

BetMGM First Bet Offer $1,500
About the Author

Nick Hennion

Read More @nickhennion

Nick Hennion is a senior content writer for BetMGM. His previous stops include VSiN, NBC Sports, The Action Network and Forbes Betting. He owns a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University and a master's degree from Northwestern University.

Nick Hennion is a senior content writer for BetMGM. His previous stops include VSiN, NBC Sports, The Action Network and Forbes Betting. He owns a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University and a master's degree from Northwestern University.