The record for most fumbles lost in a single Super Bowl is eight. The Dallas Cowboys and Buffalo Bills combined for eight lost fumbles — and 12 total fumbles — in Super Bowl XXVII.
Most Fumbles in a Super Bowl By a Player
No NFL player has ever had more than three fumbles lost in a single Super Bowl. Three different quarterbacks share the unfortunate single-game record.
Initially, it was Cowboys quarterback Roger Staubach in Super Bowl X who set the record with three lost fumbles. The Steelers won 21-17, continuing the Steel Curtain dynasty.
Then, 16 years later, Jim Kelly lost three fumbles against Washington in Super Bowl XXVI. The Redskins won 37-24.
Just one year later, Kelly and the Bills were back in the Super Bowl. But as you may know, the tale of the 90s Bills’ Super Bowl appearances is not a happy one.
Kelly had already turned the ball over three times by the early part of the second quarter, and that’s when he took a sack from Cowboys linebacker Ken Norton Jr. Kelly’s knee was reinjured, forcing him from the game. Backup Frank Reich entered.
So just one year after Kelly had fumbled three times, and in a new Super Bowl where Kelly had already turned the ball over three times, Frank Reich proceeded to fumble three times of his own, joining his teammate on an ignominious historical list.
The Cowboys ultimately won 52-17 after an avalanche of nine total Buffalo turnovers.
The obvious lesson that you probably didn’t need to hear from me: It’s hard to win the Super Bowl when you turn the ball over several times.
NFL Lines at BetMGM
From the preseason through the postseason, BetMGM has updated NFL lines for every game every year.
From over/under totals and moneylines to prop bets and parlays, there’s non-stop action at the online sportsbook.